ChatGPT Prompts for Follow Up Messages: 10 That Work

10 ChatGPT prompts for follow up messages to brokers, bankers and owners, with the context block to paste in and the limits no prompt can fix.

By Brett Kaufman. 8 years using relationships to build sales pipelines, from political fundraising to a 7 figure business to running matchmaking for two communities. Over 1,000 introductions facilitated.

The ChatGPT prompts for follow up messages that work give the model three things it cannot guess: who the person is to you, the one real reason you are writing today, and how you actually text. Below are 10 prompts built that way, a context block to reuse, and an honest list of what no prompt can do.

You are in the car after lunch with a broker. You open ChatGPT and type “write a follow up to a business broker I just met.” It hands you four sentences that start with “I hope this message finds you well” and end with “I look forward to staying connected.” You would never send that, so you send nothing.

The prompt was not the problem. The context was.

What makes a ChatGPT prompt for a follow up text work?

A follow up prompt works when most of it is facts about the relationship and very little of it is instructions. ChatGPT is a good writer with no memory of your lunch. Give it the lunch.

Here is the context block I would paste at the top of every prompt. Fill it in once per person.

Who: [first name], [role] at [firm]. We met [where, when].
What they told me: [one specific thing, in their words if possible].
Last touch: [date] and what was said.
Reason today: [the real, dated reason I am writing now].
Ask: [the one thing I want, or "no ask"].
How I text: short, no exclamation points, no "hope you're well",
no "circling back", no "just checking in". Under 40 words.
Write it like a text, not an email. Give me 3 options.

That block is the information most pages on this topic skip. The ten prompts below assume it sits on top.

The 10 ChatGPT prompts for follow up messages

Each one goes under the context block. Swap the brackets.

  1. Same day, after you meet. “Write a text to send tonight. Reference what they told me. No ask, just make it easy for them to remember who I am.”
  2. A broker you have not talked to in six months. “We have not spoken since [month]. Do not apologize for the gap. Open with the reason today and ask one easy question about what they are seeing in [industry].”
  3. Passing on a deal without closing the door. “I am passing on [deal]. Say why in one line, specific to my criteria, and tell them exactly what I would jump on next.”
  4. Congratulations on a closed deal. “They just closed [deal], posted on [date]. Congratulate them on the specific deal, not on success in general. No ask.”
  5. Asking for a warm intro. “Ask if they would be open to introducing me to [name]. Give the one line reason it helps [name], not me. Make it easy to say no.”
  6. Thanking someone for an intro. “They introduced me to [name] on [date]. Thank them and tell them what came of it in one line, even if it was small.”
  7. An owner who said not yet. “They told me on [date] they were not ready to sell. Mention the thing they said mattered to them. No pressure, no ask about selling.”
  8. After a call with a banker. “Recap the one next step we agreed on and the date. Nothing else.”
  9. Make it sound like me. “Here are five texts I actually sent: [paste]. Rewrite your draft to match their length, punctuation and tone.”
  10. Strip the tells. “Cut every phrase that sounds like a template. Cut any adjective I would not say out loud. If it is over 40 words, cut it in half.”

Prompts 9 and 10 matter most. More on why in whether AI drafted texts can sound like you.

Which prompt fits which moment?

Match the moment to the prompt, then check what you must paste before you hit enter.

Moment Prompt What you must paste in
Met someone today 1 Where you met, one thing they said
Six months of silence 2 Last touch date, a real reason today
Passing on a teaser 3 Your criteria, what you want next
They closed or got promoted 4 The post, opened and confirmed by you
You need an intro 5 Who, and why it helps them
An intro just landed 6 The date and the outcome
Owner not ready 7 What they said mattered to them
Banker call done 8 The agreed next step
Any draft 9 and 10 Five of your own sent texts

The right column is the work. ChatGPT does the middle column in seconds.

What can’t ChatGPT do for follow up messages?

ChatGPT cannot tell you who to write to. Every limit below comes back to that.

It does not know who went quiet. It has never seen your phone. It cannot look at 800 contacts and notice the banker you have not texted since spring. You have to bring it the name, and the names you forget are the ones that cost you.

It cannot confirm a post is theirs. Ask it about “Mike, a broker in Dallas” and it may answer confidently about the wrong Mike. Congratulating the wrong person is worse than silence. Open the post yourself before prompt 4.

It does not keep a ledger. ChatGPT has a memory feature, and OpenAI is clear it does not retain every detail from every conversation. That is fine for “I like short texts.” It is not a record of what each of 800 people told you.

It drifts generic when context is thin. People who know you are not fooled by polish. They notice when a text does not fit you. That is the real risk, covered in can people tell AI wrote a message.

It does not send, and it does not follow up on the follow up. You still copy, paste and remember to do it again next month.

Here is how I would run it

In political fundraising, my edge was the details I logged after every call: kids’ names, teams, what they told me about their business. The prompt above is just that log, handed to a faster writer. If you do not keep the log, the prompt has nothing to work with.

So here is the setup I would use if ChatGPT were my only tool.

  1. Make a ChatGPT project called Follow Ups. Paste the “How I text” lines and five of your real texts into its instructions.
  2. After every meeting, paste the filled context block the same day. After an event, run it inside a conference follow up system.
  3. Keep a separate list of your top 50 people with the last touch date, and check it weekly.
  4. Open every post yourself before you mention it.
  5. Read every draft out loud. Send only what you would say.

That works for 50 people. It is also manual tracking with a nicer writer, and that is the part that breaks. The tradeoffs are laid out in can I use ChatGPT as a personal CRM.

The version that fills in the context for you

Full disclosure: I built FRONT OF MIND, so weigh this part accordingly. I built it because the context block is the hard part, and I wanted something that fills it in before I open my phone.

It opens on your 10 minutes for today. Each person has a one line reason why today: they posted, it is their birthday, you met at an event 12 days ago and never followed up, a deal in your pipeline has been quiet 7 days, their company was in the news, or the relationship is going cold. Posts only show if they are confirmed to belong to that person.

Each one comes with a text style draft, 40 words max. Nothing sends without your tap, and it learns from your edits. At an event, say a name and a sentence out loud, snap a card or badge, or take a selfie together, and it is filed under that event.

There is no native iPhone app yet. It runs in your phone browser and you can save it to your home screen. Your contacts are encrypted. No one on our team looks at them. Export and delete anytime.

Keep the prompts. Let something else tell you who they are for. Start free with your first 25 contacts and see who comes up first.

See how it works

Join The Connector

One networking tip, one template, one story, one app feature highlight. Every Tuesday.