What to Do When an Intro You Made Goes Nowhere
Your intro stalled. The four reasons it happens, the exact texts to send each side at 2 weeks and 30 days, when to let it go, and how to protect your name.
By Brett Kaufman. 8 years using relationships to build sales pipelines, from political fundraising to a 7 figure business to running matchmaking for two communities. Over 1,000 introductions facilitated.
When an intro you made goes nowhere, it almost always stalled for one of four reasons: no clear next step, wrong timing, one side did not care, or it happened and nobody told you. Find out which with one short text to each side at 2 weeks and again at 30 days, then either restart it, close it kindly or let it go.
Here is how it looks from your side. Three weeks ago you connected an operator buying commercial cleaning companies with a CPA who has two owners thinking about selling. Both said thanks. The thread went quiet the same day. You have not heard a word since, and you do not know if that means nothing happened or everything did.
I have facilitated over 1,000 introductions and I run matchmaking for two communities. Not every intro lands, and that is fine. What I tell people is that the intro is only half the job. The check is the other half.
The four reasons intros stall
1. No clear next step. You wrote a good intro and nobody owned the first move. Each side waited politely for the other. This is the most common one and the easiest to fix.
2. Wrong timing. The fit was real, but one side is buried. The buyer is in diligence on another deal. The CPA is in tax season. Nothing is wrong except the calendar.
3. One side did not care. You saw a fit they did not. Fred Wilson put the receiving side’s view plainly in his post on the double opt in introduction: “All of us get email intros that we don’t want to follow up on.” If you sent a cold cc, this is the likely answer.
4. It happened and nobody told you. They had the call. Maybe they are already working together. People thank the connector once, in the thread, and then forget the connector exists. This one feels like a dead intro and is often the best one you made.
You cannot tell these apart from silence. You can tell them apart from one text.
At 2 weeks: one text to each side
Send them separately, not in the group thread. A private text lets someone tell you the truth, including “not interested.”
To the side with more to gain:
Did you and Dana ever connect? No pressure either way. If it helps, I can nudge her and suggest a time.
To the side with more to lose:
Quick one. Did Mike reach out? Totally fine if the timing is off on your end, just want to make sure I did not hand you a dead thread.
Both are under 40 words. Neither asks for a report. Each gives an easy out, which is what gets you an honest answer.
What you hear back sorts the intro:
- “We keep missing each other.” Reason 1. Assign the move. “Mike, grab two times this week and send them to Dana.”
- “Swamped until next month.” Reason 2. Agree on a date and write it down.
- “Honestly not a fit for us.” Reason 3. Thank them and stop.
- “Oh, we talked last week.” Reason 4. Ask how it went and log the answer.
At 30 days: the second and last check
If the 2 week text restarted things, the 30 day text is a quick confirmation. If it did not, this is the last nudge.
To the side with more to gain:
One more on Dana. If it is not the right fit, no worries at all. I would rather find you someone better than push this one.
To the side with more to lose:
Last note on Mike, promise. If now is not the time, just say so and I will tell him timing is off. No explanation needed.
The phrase “no explanation needed” matters. It lets the busier person say no without writing a paragraph, and it tells them you will protect them when you report back.
When to let it go
Let it go when any of these is true:
- One side has said no, in any words.
- You have sent both checks and one side has stayed silent through both.
- The reason you made the intro has expired. The deal closed, the mandate filled, the owner decided not to sell.
Letting go is not ghosting. Close the loop with the side still waiting:
Checked with Dana, the timing is not right on her side. I will keep an eye out for someone who fits better.
Do not pass along the reason. Do not apologize for the other person. Then log it: both names, the date, and what happened. The entry stops you from asking the same person about the same intro again in two months.
How to protect your reputation
Your name is the part of the intro that does not expire. These are the rules I would never skip.
Ask before you connect. Most reason 3 stalls come from intros the busier side never agreed to. A double opt in intro takes one extra text and removes the most damaging kind of dead intro.
Name who moves first. Every intro should end with one person told to send times. That alone prevents most reason 1 stalls.
Never chase past two checks. A third nudge to a silent lender or investor costs more than the intro was worth. The people with the most to lose remember who respects their time.
Close every loop out loud. The side waiting on an answer would rather hear “not this one” than nothing. Silence from you reads like you forgot, which is worse than an intro that did not work.
Learn from the ledger. Over a year, patterns show. Maybe your lender intros convert and your “you two should grab coffee” intros never do. That tells you which intros to make on purpose, and which to stop making.
The same discipline applies when a deal itself stalls. The first week matters, and what to do when a deal goes quiet covers that side. And the check is how people move from knowing your name to sending you their next deal. They remember who followed through.
Why intros die in silence at volume
None of this is hard for one intro. It is hard for thirty. You made four intros at a dinner, six more on calls, and two at an event the week after. The 2 week mark for each one lands on a different day, on a week you are traveling. Nobody remembers to check, so every stalled intro looks the same as every successful one: silent.
The system that checks for you
That is the part I built FRONT OF MIND to carry. When a follow up is due, the person shows up in your 10 minutes for today with a one line reason why today and a drafted text style message, 40 words max. Nothing sends without your tap, and it learns from your edits.
Capture the intro the moment you make it. Say the two names and a sentence out loud after dinner, and it is filed under the event. When an intro dies and you want a better fit, ask Liala “who do I know that is an SBA lender” and get the right people with why. Intros to make this week come with dated proof on both sides, so the next one starts with a reason that is current.
Your contacts are encrypted. No one on our team looks at them. Export and delete anytime.
Start free with your first 25 contacts and 1 intro, and see which stalled intro comes up first.